bug bottles vs qpcr

Bug Bottles vs qPCR – What’s the Difference?

What are ‘Bug Bottles’?

As highlighted in a previous blog, microbes can cause a range of microbiological problems in oil and gas extraction processes. By controlling microbial growth, operators can prevent issues such as:

Various methods are available for monitoring levels of problematic groups of bacteria, like acid-producers and sulfate-reducers. One method that has a well-established history, is the serial dilution most probable number (MPN) culture test, often referred to as “Bug Bottles.” This is a visual method, where the sample is serially diluted in a number of bottles containing growth media, allowed to incubate, and then the MPN is estimated based on the number of bottles that change colour.


The MPN culture test method is simple and easy to interpret, but there are a few limitations:

  • incubation times can be significant, requiring up to 28 days depending on the microbe that’s being targeted.
  • approximately <1% of microorganisms are culturable, so culture-based results can significantly underestimate the total concentration or overestimate biocide efficacy.


What is qPCR?

A great alternative that has recently gained in popularity is quantitative Polymerase Chain Reaction (qPCR). This is a DNA-based method that can be used to rapidly detect and quantify microorganisms in environmental or industrial samples. Like with serial dilution culture tests, different qPCR assays can be used to identify concentrations of key groups, such as total prokaryotes, sulfate-reducing prokaryotes, or iron-reducing bacteria.


Unlike culture-based methods, qPCR has the advantage of being:

  • fast, sensitive, and highly specific.
  • results can be obtained within 2.5 hours of sample collection and it does not rely on microbial growth, so it is not limited to only detecting culturable microorganisms.
  • it can also be used to process a variety of sample types, such as liquids, solids, and coupons.

Historically, qPCR testing could be relatively complex compared to culture-based tests, but LuminUltra’s GeneCountTM qPCR provides a complete off-the-shelf solution with assay kits that were designed and optimized for identifying key target organisms in contaminated samples from industrial, oil & gas, and wastewater facilities. The GeneCount qPCR test also provides an excellent complement to 2nd Generation ATP testing, as ATP can be used for routine, day-to-day monitoring, while GeneCount qPCR can be used for weekly or monthly monitoring, with additional testing for diagnosing any identified issues.


Be sure to check out our GeneCount brochure to learn more about our DNA-based products and services.

Brad Mcilwain

Brad McIlwain has over eight years of experience in the water and wastewater industry. Prior to joining LuminUltra, he worked for several years as a consulting engineer, where he helped solve complex water and wastewater treatment process issues. He has a particular interest in water system corrosion. During his Master’s, his research focused on water quality and corrosion in premise plumbing. Brad enjoys being outdoors, spending as many weekends as possible camping, hiking, and cycling.

Related Posts

What’s in a name? Three Intricacies of Organism Names in NGS Data

  There’s no universal method for cataloging organisms or for converting sequencing data to taxonomic data, so careful examination of methodology, as well as the results, is needed when analyzing DNA-associated data. Three of the intricacies are discussed below: Candidatus The formal naming of organisms is determined by a set of rules called the International… Read More

How to use ATP and DNA in a Wastewater Nitrification Monitoring Plan

Ammonia removal is a key metric for assessing wastewater treatment facility performance. This is because ammonia contributes to aquatic life toxicity. Furthermore, nitrogen, along with phosphorus, is a driver of receiving water eutrophication. Eutrophication, which simply is an over-enrichment of nutrients, can be detrimental to environmental and public health. It can result in harmful algae… Read More

Solution Highlight: GeneCount NGS Services

Sequencing of the 16S rRNA gene LuminUltra’s GeneCount® Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) service takes microbial monitoring to the “next” level by sequencing the 16S rRNA gene, which is present in all bacteria and archaea. This gene contains sections that allow individual organisms to be differentiated from one another and classified to the genus level. Based… Read More

© 2020 LuminUltra |