Sequencing Your Bioreactor – Who’s Doing the Work?


Metagenomics through the incorporation of next generation sequencing (NGS) is changing the way wastewater treatment plants are monitored and understood. NGS can be used in aerobic and anaerobic systems to monitor for problematic organisms, such as filamentous and foaming bacteria, and beneficial organisms, such as ammonia-oxidizing bacteria and methanogens.

NGS is also allowing old assumptions about treatment mechanisms to be questioned. A good example of this is enhanced biological phosphorus removal (EBPR). EBPR was first documented in the early 1970’s. Traditionally it has been understood that EBPR requires a first stage anaerobic zone that is free of nitrate and nitrite. In the anaerobic zone, phosphorus accumulating organisms (PAO) utilize energy from stored polyphosphate to assimilate volatile fatty acids (VFAs) and produce polyhydroxybutyrate storage products. In subsequent aerobic zones, polyhydroxybutyrate storage products are used to provide energy for new cell growth and the formation of new internal polyphosphate bonds. A recent article in Water Environmental Research presented by Barnard, Dunlap and Steichen showed that in fact, EBPR mechanisms are much more complex and conventional EBPR processes may have been unintentionally selecting for less efficient PAOs.

It was understood that PAOs required VFAs, specifically acetic or propanoic acid, in the anaerobic zone. In the early days, this explained why EBPR processes worked better in hot climates where fermentation readily occurs in the sewage collection system. In systems with insufficient VFAs, an external sludge fermentation process needed to be added to supplement the PAOs. However, the reliance on VFAs is only true for some PAOs, such as Accumulibacter. There is also a group of PAOs, such as Tetrasphaera, that do not rely on VFAs and can perform fermentation as well as phosphorus accumulation. Tetrasphaera requires extended residence times in environments with a low ORP (<200 mV) to perform fermentation. Conventional EBPR processes – where all the primary effluent passes through the first stage anaerobic zone – is not conducive to Tetrasphaera fermentation because the residence time is too short and the ORP is too high. Alternative configurations – where a small, controlled portion of the primary effluent is sent to anaerobic zone (with the remaining flow bypassed to the anoxic or aerobic zone) – is more favourable to Tetrasphaera growth. In these alternate configurations, Tetrasphaera has been shown to have higher abundances relative to Accumulibacter.

Advancements in metagenomics is allowing us to question old assumptions about wastewater treatment. This includes assumptions about the unit processes (ie. side stream vs first stage anaerobic zones) and the operational metrics (ie. SRT, solids inventory) required to achieve treatment. Understanding the microbial community composition through metagenomics can drastically increase the operational knowledge of a treatment plant. Tetrasphaera and Accumulibacter can both accomplish EBPR, however the mechanism is very different.

Interested in sequencing your wastewater treatment plant? LuminUltra can help! LuminUltra offers easy sampling and preservation kits, a powerful and easy to understand dashboard and fast turnaround times. Contact us today to incorporate NGS into your monitoring program.


Further reading:

Brochure – DNA tools – qPCR and NGS


Jordan Schmidt

Jordan has a PhD in Civil Engineering specializing in biological wastewater treatment. During his PhD, Jordan contributed to full-scale field evaluations of municipal waste stabilization ponds in the Canadian territory of Nunavut. He has a diverse background of expertise including data science, experimental design, statistical programming and full-scale municipal wastewater treatment. When he’s not working, Jordan enjoys sea kayaking, backcountry camping in Kejimkujik National Park and rock climbing.

Related Posts

Top 3 Questions from WEFTEC17

  WEFTEC17 proved to be one of the best ones yet for LuminUltra! Here are top three questions we were asked: 1. Can you measure ATP in anaerobic systems? Yes, ATP can be measured in aerobic, anoxic and anaerobic systems. ATP is a measure of total biomass and is not specific to any one functional… Read More

Top 3 Things I Learned at WEFTEC 2018

  Whether I’m talking to attendees or customers in our booth at WEFTEC, or attending presentations, I always walk away with valuable information. That is the key, as you’ll see in my #1 take-away from WEFTEC.   1. Data ≠ Information I initially heard this statement during Dr. Mark van Loosdrecht’s presentation on wastewater microbial… Read More

Ultimate Monitoring Solution for Biological Wastewater Treatment [Infographic]

Wastewater treatment plant staff do their best to optimize the health of microbes in their bioreactor. However, without a direct way to measure active biomass, process optimization is very difficult achieve. Additionally, toxicity occurrence can cause the plant to deviate from effluent quality compliance and result in violations. These events tend to happen with little… Read More