Skip to Main Content
LuminUltra
EnglishFrançais简体中文

Why won’t total microbial content decrease after UV treatment?

 

UV treatment only recently became widely adopted in the water and wastewater treatment industries but the benefits of sun exposure for water purification have been acknowledged for thousands of years. Ancient Sanskrit and Greek writings dating as far back as 4,000 B.C. identify exposure to sunlight as one of the recommended water treatment methods to improve the taste, odor, and clarity of drinking water. It wasn’t until the mid-1800’s however, with John Snow’s theory on cholera transmission and Robert Koch’s agar development, that we began to identify microbiological pathogens and the risks associated with them. In 1877, the germicidal properties of sunlight were discovered by Downes and Blunt and in 1910 in Marseilles, France, the first UV disinfection system for drinking water was operated. UV disinfection was still slow to gain traction in the industry until the 1970’s with the discovery of disinfection by-products (DBPs).

With new developments in water quality monitoring methods and metagenomics, we are now keenly aware of the risks posed by microbial pathogens and, with increasing concern of DBPs from chemical addition, UV treatment has gained significant popularity as a non-chemical disinfectant with thousands of plants now operating across North America.

What does UV treatment mean for microbes and why don’t we see a decrease in ATP levels if it’s so effective as a disinfectant?

Compared to chlorine, which destroys the cell membrane, UV treatment is a physical process where UV light mutates and/or degrades DNA and RNA in bacterial and viral cells. The violet-blue spectrum is most effective and 254 nm provides the maximum germicidal effect against most microbes. Although the cells remain alive, damaged DNA/RNA prevents the cell from reproducing, leaving them non-culturable and reducing the risk to consumers. This, however, makes it possible for ‘false-negatives’ to occur with traditional culture-based compliance tests. Because the bacterial concentration remains relatively consistent immediately before and after treatment, ATP – still safely within the cell membranes – often shows no significant change until hours after treatment when the cells have had time to die off. A recent trial done with UV treated wastewater effluent, showed a significant decrease in ATP levels only after 24 hours:

Research also shows that UV treated cells can enter a dormant state from which they can later wake up and begin reproducing again. This poses a potential risk for utilities relying solely on UV disinfection. Xin Yu, a researcher at the Chinese Academy of Science’s Institution of Urban Environment found that, although plate counts showed a ~99% decrease in bacterial concentration after UV treatment, qPCR demonstrated that most bacteria remained alive and retained the ability to synthesize proteins. Under the right conditions, these cells – both E.coli and P.aeruginosa – were able to come back to life and continue reproducing, suggesting that plate counts may underestimate the size of the viable population. Although the risk is low, the research confirms that UV treatment should not be relied upon alone and should be paired with low doses of disinfectants for optimal efficacy.

While ATP can’t be used to immediately gauge UV treatment efficacy, it can be used as a tool to monitor changes in the size of the total biological population over time, and under different conditions, to assess overall risk and optimize process efficiency.

 


LuminUltra Team

Founded in 1995, LuminUltra is a molecular biology diagnostic testing company headquartered in Canada with operations in 6 countries. It is widely recognized globally as a leader in developing tests and reagents for environmental, industrial, and diagnostic monitoring applications and is a key supplier of COVID-19 diagnostic testing reagents to the Government of Canada.

Dozens of Fortune 500 customers across more than 80 countries trust LuminUltra’s technology, production reliability and history of customer service excellence to deliver their essential services in a safe state.

Related Posts

Hurricane Season

  With the start of the 2018 hurricane season right around the corner, many people living in the Caribbean and along the Gulf of Mexico and Atlantic coasts of North America are holding their collective breath. The 2017 season produced a series of storms that resulted in significant loss of life as well as billions… Read More

Most Wanted Microbes – Nitrifiers (a.k.a. Nitrosomonas)

  From the editor: This is the fourth post in an ongoing series profiling microorganisms of particular significance in water and wastewater systems. In this series we will cover microorganisms of many types including some that are beneficial, inhibitory and pathogenic.  Nitrification is a two-part process whereby ammonia is converted to nitrate. The first step… Read More

Your browser is out of date!

Update your browser to view this website correctly. Update my browser now